AI Music Creation: Suno vs Udio vs ElevenLabs Music – My Comprehensive Experience After 6 Months of Testing

Look, I'm going to save you some time right now: if you're a content creator still paying hundreds of dollars per track for music, you're doing it wrong. I know because I was that person six months ago.

I was dropping anywhere from $200 to $300 per track for my YouTube videos. Sometimes more. And it was absolutely killing my margins. So when I started hearing about AI music generation, I figured – what the hell, let's see if this stuff actually works.

Spoiler alert: it works. Really well, actually.

But here's the thing nobody tells you: not all AI music platforms are created equal. I've spent the last six months testing Suno, Udio, and ElevenLabs Music. I've generated over 500 tracks, burned through $400 in subscriptions, and learned way more than I wanted to know about AI-generated music.

This is everything I wish someone had told me before I started.

The TL;DR (If You're in a Hurry)

Suno is stupid fast and stupid cheap. Great for YouTubers and anyone who needs volume.

Udio sounds professional – like, actually professional. Use it when quality matters.

ElevenLabs Music is best for instrumental stuff and if you're already using their voice tools.

Still with me? Cool. Let's get into it.

How I Got Here (And Why You Should Care)

Six months ago, I was running a YouTube channel and doing video production for clients. Music licensing was eating me alive financially. I'd spend hours browsing stock music sites, trying to find something that didn't sound like every other YouTuber's background track.

Then someone in a Facebook group mentioned Suno. I signed up, typed in "upbeat indie pop with summer vibes," and 40 seconds later I had a complete song. Intro, verses, chorus, outro – the whole thing.

I literally sat there staring at my screen thinking "there's no way this is real."

But it was real. And it was actually good.

That's when I decided to go all-in. I wanted to test everything, compare everything, and figure out which platform was actually worth using. Because let's be honest – most reviews out there are either written by people who tested each platform for 20 minutes, or they're just regurgitating marketing copy.

I wanted real answers. So I generated hundreds of tracks, used them in actual projects, and tracked everything.

Suno: The One That Started It All

Suno's interface looks like Spotify had a baby with ChatGPT. It's clean, simple, and you can start generating music within 30 seconds of signing up. You've got two modes: Simple and Custom. Simple mode is exactly what it sounds like – you describe what you want, hit generate, and boom. Music. Custom mode lets you write your own lyrics and get more specific with genres.

I use Simple mode like 70% of the time because honestly, the AI usually knows what I want better than I do.

What's Actually Good About Suno

It's Ridiculously Fast

I'm talking 30-60 seconds for a complete, full-length song. Not a clip. Not a loop. A full song with everything. I tracked this obsessively (because I'm that kind of person), and the average was 43 seconds. My fastest generation was 28 seconds. When you're pumping out content and need music NOW, this speed is a lifesaver.

One time a client called me at 2 PM saying they needed different music for a video going live at 5 PM. I generated five completely different options in under 10 minutes. Try doing that with traditional music licensing.

The Vocals Are Shockingly Good

Here's something that genuinely surprised me: the vocals don't immediately scream "AI." I made a country ballad for a client video about rural America. Three different people asked me who the singer was. When I told them it was AI-generated, they literally didn't believe me.

Now, if you're listening with expensive headphones or you're an audio engineer, yeah, you can tell. There's this subtle processed quality to it. But in the context of a YouTube video or social media post? Most people can't tell the difference.

Suno recently updated to version 4.5, and the improvements are noticeable. Songs feel more structured, genres are more accurate, and there are fewer of those weird transitions where the song just... doesn't know what to do with itself.

What's Not So Great

That "Suno Sound"

After you've generated maybe 50 or 60 songs, you start to notice something. There's this distinctive quality to Suno's output – like everything has a subtle auto-tune effect applied, even when you didn't ask for it. I played some tracks for my friend who's an audio engineer (without telling him they were AI), and he immediately said "these sound processed." That's the Suno sound.

Lyrics Can Be... Weird

Sometimes Suno writes poetry. Sometimes it writes complete nonsense. I asked it to create a rock song about overcoming obstacles. This is what I got:

"My bass line is playing loud and clear
The drums are beating, drawing near
Guitar strings singing, free from fear"

Like... what? It's literally just describing the instruments instead of, you know, obstacles. This happens more than I'd like to admit.

Extensions Don't Always Work

Out of 100 songs I tried to extend, 15 just... didn't work. Error messages, freezing, or it would just silently fail. When you're on a deadline, this is incredibly frustrating.

The Real Numbers

I used Suno Pro ($10/month) for three months. Here's what happened:

• Generated: 437 songs
• Actually used: 89 songs
• Success rate: About 20%
• Cost per usable track: $0.34

Compare that to the $200-300 I was paying before. Even with only a 20% success rate, I'm saving literally thousands of dollars.

Udio: The Quality Option

I was comfortable with Suno. I knew how it worked, I was getting results, and I'm fundamentally lazy. Why learn a new platform? But I kept seeing audio professionals on Reddit saying Udio sounded better. Like, significantly better. So I figured I'd give it a shot.

And yeah, they were right.

The Sound Quality Is Actually Professional

This is Udio's secret weapon: it genuinely sounds like professional music production.

I'm not going to bore you with all the technical specs, but here's what matters: Udio outputs at 48kHz/32-bit. That's studio quality. When I drop an Udio track into my video editing timeline next to commercially licensed music, I literally cannot tell the difference in quality.

The Vocals Sound Human

This is where Udio really shines. I created a sad piano ballad and played it for my wife without telling her it was AI. She got emotional listening to it. When I told her afterwards that a computer made it, she was genuinely shocked.

The voice has texture. It has emotion. There's breath, there's tremor, there's... feeling. It's honestly kind of creepy how good it is.

More Control (If You Want It)

Udio gives you way more control than Suno:

• You can upload your own audio and have it generate from that
• You can use "inpainting" to change specific parts of a song
• You can extend songs manually with precise control
• You can fine-tune how genre tags get interpreted

For a corporate video where I needed music to hit specific emotional beats at exact timestamps, this level of control was essential. Suno would've been guessing.

The Downsides

There's a Learning Curve

Udio is not as immediately intuitive as Suno. It took me about a week of daily use before I felt comfortable with all the features. When I just need generic background music fast, I still go back to Suno. Udio is for when I have time to actually craft something.

It's Slower

Udio generates 30-second clips that you then extend manually. To get a full 3-minute song, you're looking at:

• Initial generation: 30 seconds
• Then 6-8 extension steps
• Total time: 5-10 minutes

Compared to Suno's instant complete songs, this feels slow. But the quality difference is worth it for important projects.

Sometimes too literal. When I ask Udio for "blues rock," it gives me BLUES ROCK. Like, textbook definition blues rock. Sometimes Suno's occasional genre-blending creates more interesting results.

My Real Usage

I used Udio Standard ($10/month) for two months:

• Generated: 178 songs
• Used in projects: 67 songs
• Success rate: 37.6%
• Cost per usable track: $0.30

Better quality, higher success rate, but slower workflow and fewer total generations.

ElevenLabs Music

ElevenLabs built their reputation on text-to-speech and voice cloning. They're really good at it. So when they announced music generation, I was skeptical. Turns out they're not trying to compete head-to-head with Suno and Udio. They're building an ecosystem.

ElevenLabs isn't just a music platform. It's:

• Text-to-speech
• Voice cloning
• Music generation
• Translation and dubbing

For someone like me who uses both AI voice and AI music, this integration is actually really convenient. I can generate a voiceover and matching background music in the same workflow.

Where It Works Really Well

Super Fast for Instrumentals

Need ambient background music? Corporate soundtrack? Podcast bed? ElevenLabs cranks these out in 25-30 seconds. I use it all the time for tutorial videos where I just need something simple and unobtrusive in the background.

The Credit System Is Actually Smart

Instead of paying per song, you get credits that work across all ElevenLabs features. So if I don't use all my music credits one month, I can use them for voiceover instead. This flexibility is nice when your needs vary month to month.

Where It Falls Short

Vocals Aren't Great

I tested 20 vocal song requests on ElevenLabs. Three were usable. The rest sounded robotic and emotionally flat. If you need songs with singing, use Suno or Udio. ElevenLabs is for instrumentals.

Less Customization

Compared to Udio's detailed controls or even Suno's custom mode, ElevenLabs is pretty basic. You describe what you want, you get what you get.

My Real Usage

One month on Creator plan ($22/month):

• Generated: 47 minutes of music
• Actually used: 31 tracks
• Success rate: 65.9%
• Cost per track: $0.35

Highest success rate of all three platforms, but I only use it for specific instrumental needs.

Head-to-Head: The Real Comparison

Let me cut through the BS and tell you exactly how these platforms compare.

Speed Test

I generated the same 3-minute track request on all three platforms:

• Suno: 45 seconds (complete song instantly)
• ElevenLabs: 28 seconds (instrumental only)
• Udio: 8 minutes (multiple extension steps)

Winner: Suno for songs with vocals, ElevenLabs for instrumentals.

Quality Test

I played tracks from each platform for 10 people (mix of audio professionals and regular folks):

Suno: 7 out of 10 people identified it as AI within 30 seconds

Udio: Only 3 out of 10 were confident it was AI. Two people insisted it was a real singer until I showed them proof.

ElevenLabs: 9 out of 10 knew immediately (but I only tested instrumental versions)

Winner: Udio, no contest.

Genre Accuracy Test

I asked each platform to generate 10 different genres:

Winner: Udio.

Real-World Project Test

I used all three platforms for actual client work over two months:

Suno tracks (23 used): Zero complaints, one client thought it was a demo version of a real song

Udio tracks (31 used): Multiple clients complimented the music choice, one asked for artist info to credit them

ElevenLabs tracks (18 used): Worked perfectly for background scoring, no issues raised

Winner: All three work fine for real projects. Choice depends on your specific needs.

Let's Talk About Pricing

Here's what these platforms actually cost and what you get for your money.

Suno Pricing

Free: 50 credits daily (10 songs). Can't use commercially. Good for testing.

Pro ($10/month): 500 songs monthly, commercial rights, priority queue. This is the sweet spot.

Premier ($30/month): 2,000 songs monthly. Overkill unless you're an agency.

My take: Pro at $10/month is all most people will ever need. I never used more than 200 songs in a month even when I was cranking out content.

Udio Pricing

Free: 10 credits daily. Limited but functional for testing.

Standard ($10/month): More credits, audio uploads, high-quality exports. Good value.

Pro ($30/month): Substantially more credits, early access to features. Only needed for high-volume work.

My take: Standard at $10/month is the right choice for most people.

ElevenLabs Pricing

Free: 11 minutes of music monthly. Not much.

Starter ($5/month): 22 minutes monthly. Still pretty limiting.

Creator ($22/month): 62 minutes monthly, commercial license. This is their main plan.

Pro ($99/month): 304 minutes monthly. For heavy users.

My take: The minute-based pricing feels more restrictive than Suno/Udio's song-based model. Only worth it if you're also using their voice features.

The Real Cost Breakdown

Let me show you what these subscriptions actually cost per usable track:

Compare to traditional licensing: $200-300 per track.

Over six months, I went from spending $1,200 on music to spending $120. That's $1,080 saved.

When to Use Which Platform

Okay, here's the practical stuff. When should you actually use each platform?

Use Suno When:

• You need music RIGHT NOW
• You're making YouTube videos or social content
• Volume matters more than perfection
• You're on a tight budget
• You want to try multiple ideas quickly

When client calls at 2 PM, needs new music by 5 PM. Suno generates five options in 10 minutes. Project saved.

Use Udio When:

• Quality actually matters
• You're doing client work with real budgets
• The music is a main feature, not just background
• You have time to iterate and refine
• Audio professionals might hear it

Documentary video about climate change. Spent 4 hours crafting Udio soundtrack. Multiple YouTube comments praised the "amazing music."

Use ElevenLabs When:

• You need simple instrumental backgrounds
• You're also doing voiceover work
• You want everything in one platform
• Making tutorials or podcasts
• Corporate video work

Weekly podcast. Generated intro music and voice intro in same session, matching aesthetic.

My Honest Recommendation

After six months of testing, here's what I actually use and what I recommend.

If You Can Only Choose One: Suno

For most content creators, Suno Pro at $10/month is all you need. It's:

• Fast enough for any deadline
• Good enough for 90% of projects
• Cheap enough to experiment freely
• Simple enough to learn in 30 minutes

Start here. Seriously.

My Personal Setup: Two Platforms

I use Suno Pro ($10/month) + Udio Standard ($10/month) = $20/month total

Why both?

• Suno for 80% of projects (speed, volume, experimentation)
• Udio for 20% of projects (important client work, portfolio pieces)

This combo covers basically everything. Total cost is still less than ONE traditionally licensed track.

If You're Really Serious: Add ElevenLabs

Only add ElevenLabs Creator ($22/month) if:

• You're generating $2,000+ monthly from content
• You do a lot of voiceover work
• You need both voice and music regularly

I tried running all three subscriptions for two months. It was overkill. Stick with two unless you have a specific need.

Quick Recommendation Guide

YouTube creator → Suno Pro ($10/month)

Professional videographer → Suno Pro + Udio Standard ($20/month)

Podcaster → ElevenLabs Creator ($22/month)

Agency → Suno Pro + Udio Pro ($40/month)

Complete beginner → Start with Suno Free, upgrade to Pro after you've generated 50 songs

The Copyright Elephant in the Room

Okay, we need to talk about this because it's important.

In July 2024, the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) sued both Suno and Udio. The claim: these platforms trained their AI on copyrighted music without permission. This is a big deal. The RIAA is seeking up to $150,000 per infringement.

What This Means for You

The reality: Platforms say you can use AI music commercially on paid plans. But courts haven't ruled yet on whether the training itself was legal. You're technically taking on some legal risk by using these platforms.

For high-profile work (major brands, national campaigns): I still use traditional licensed music. The legal exposure isn't worth the savings.

For everything else (YouTube, social media, most client work): I use AI music without worry. The risk feels minimal for small-to-medium projects.

What I Do to Stay Safe

1. Keep all receipts and documentation
2. Inform clients it's AI-generated (let them decide)
3. Monitor legal developments
4. Stay ready to pivot if courts rule against AI training

Nobody's been sued for USING AI music yet. The lawsuits are about how the AI was trained. Still, stay informed.

Wrap up

Six months ago, I was skeptical. Today, I can't imagine going back.

Is AI music perfect? No. Does it replace human musicians? Absolutely not. But for content creators, it's genuinely transformative.

Here's what actually happened to my business:

Before AI Music (6 months):

• Music costs: $1,200
• Tracks purchased: 6
• Cost per track: $200

After AI Music (6 months):

• Subscription costs: $120
• Tracks generated: 615
• Usable tracks: 187
• Cost per track: $0.64

I saved $1,080. But more importantly, I can now:

• Try 10 different musical directions without budget stress
• Create custom music for every project
• Experiment freely
• Iterate until it's perfect

Don't buy all three subscriptions at once. Start small. Add platforms only when you hit specific limitations.

For 80% of content creators, Suno Pro alone will be enough.

For the other 20% who need that extra quality, add Udio.

Only add ElevenLabs if you specifically need voice + music integration.

FAQ

Quick Reference

Look, AI music isn't perfect. But neither was stock music, and we all used that for years. The question isn't whether AI music is as good as a professional composer. The question is: is it good enough for your YouTube videos, client projects, and social content?

And the answer is: absolutely yes.

For $10-20/month, you get unlimited creative freedom. You can try ideas you'd never commission traditionally. You can iterate until it's perfect. You can have custom music for every project.

Six months ago, I spent $1,200 on music. Today, I spend $20/month and get better results.

That's not the future. That's right now. And it's available to you for the price of two coffees.

Best for beginners: Suno (suno.ai)
Best audio quality: Udio (udio.com)
Best for voice + music: ElevenLabs (elevenlabs.io)

My setup: Suno Pro + Udio Standard = $20/month

Best value: Suno Pro at $10/month

Start here: Suno free plan → test it → upgrade if you like it

Related Articles:

Best AI Music Generators 2025: Free & Paid Tools Ranked

Discover the ultimate ranking of AI music generators in 2025. Compare free and paid tools like Suno AI, Udio, MusicGen, and Soundraw. Learn which platforms deliver professional-quality tracks, offer commercial licensing, and fit your budget.

Humai.blog - Al Insights, Tools & Productivity WorkflowsMark

Monetize Your Music with AI: 10 Ways Producers & Artists Can Earn Today

Discover how musicians, producers, and sound designers are using AI tools like AIVA, Mubert, and ElevenLabs to build income streams in 2025 — from royalty-free tracks to sonic branding.

Humai.blog - Al Insights, Tools & Productivity WorkflowsMark

AI Music Revolution: How It’s Changing the Industry Forever

Explore how AI is reshaping music creation, production, and distribution—unlocking new markets, creativity, and challenges for artists and fans.

Humai.blog - Al Insights, Tools & Productivity WorkflowsMark